Articles · Close More Deals

How To Run A Two-Call Close For Agency Sales

By Mark Colgan ·

Short answer: a two-call close splits the sale in two. Call one is 30 minutes of discovery with no pitch. Call two is a proposal built from what you learned, with the price at the end. Use it when the work is around $2,500 to $3,000 a month or more, or when there’s a future upsell.

What is a two-call close?

It’s what it sounds like. You don’t try to diagnose, pitch and price in one sitting.

  • Call one is for learning. You ask questions, you listen, and you book call two before you hang up.
  • Call two is for presenting. You show a plan made for them, the outcome it should produce, and then the price.

Between the two, you do some work. That’s the point.

Why not close on one call?

Because what you learn on the first call should decide what the proposal says.

On a good discovery call, the prospect tells you what they’ve tried, what went wrong and what they’d love to see. Sometimes they hand you one detail that changes the whole plan. On a one-call close you’ve already built the deck, so you can’t use it.

There’s a second reason. Most companies have similar problems, but we’re all human and we want to feel special. A proposal that plays back someone’s own numbers and their own words makes them feel understood. A deck you show to everyone doesn’t.

When is a two-call close the right choice?

My rule of thumb:

  • The work is around $2,500 to $3,000 a month or more, or
  • There’s a future upsell or cross-sell, so the first deal is the start of something bigger.

Below that, I’d usually keep it to one call. A second meeting for a small project adds delay and gives the buyer time to cool off.

This is a guide, and you know your buyers better than I do. If your prospects always need a partner’s approval, two calls may suit you even at a lower price.

How long should each call be?

For work between roughly $3,000 and $10,000 a month, this is what I do:

Call Length Purpose
Discovery 30 minutes, always Learn, qualify, book the next call
Proposal 30 or 60 minutes Present the plan, the outcome and the price
Extra call As needed Bring in other stakeholders

Be prepared for that third call. If a business partner, a finance lead or a board needs to be involved, it’s better to plan for it than to be surprised by it.

What should you do on the discovery call?

Seven things. None of them is a pitch.

1. Listen for whether they know their numbers. Most people know what a customer is worth. Fewer know their close rate off the top of their head. When someone does, I lean in. They’re on top of their business, and they tend to be more serious buyers. You don’t need to change how you ask. Just notice what comes back.

2. Mirror them. If they talk in numbers, explain your work in numbers. If they’re more about people and feel, use that language. I try to sound like the person I’m speaking to, without being fake about it.

3. Capture their real numbers. Customer value, close rate, what they’ve spent before. Write them down exactly. The deals I closed quickest this year were the ones where I knew what one new meeting was worth to the buyer, and could say what ten more a month would mean.

4. Ask before you show. If you’ve prepared ideas, ask what they’ve tried before you reveal them. I once asked a prospect if a particular company was on their target list. It was in their top ten. Then I showed them what I’d already built for that exact account. You won’t get that lucky every time, but when it lands, the buyer thinks “this person really gets my business”. And if their answers don’t match what you prepared, say these were examples made before the call and you’ll revise them.

5. Prove your point of view. If your approach rests on a belief they may be hearing for the first time, don’t just state it. Ask a question that gets them agreeing from their own experience, and back it with a proof point or a benchmark.

6. Qualify without a checklist. Offer a real start date and ask how it works for them, then ask who else needs to sign it off. I’ve covered this in how to qualify a prospect without sounding like a checklist. Be willing to qualify people out here. The proposal call is the expensive one, and you don’t want to spend it on someone who was never going to buy.

7. Book call two before you hang up. Agree the date while you’re both there. Ask if anyone else should be on it.

For the questions themselves, read how to run a discovery call.

Should you talk about price on the first call?

Not in detail. But people ask, and dodging looks odd.

Give a range, with the bottom of it above the lowest you’d accept. It tells them there are levels to the work, and it stops someone booking an hour with you expecting a tenth of the price. More on that in what to say when a prospect asks for a price too early.

If they ask whether you’ll work on performance, don’t give a flat no. Say you can look at it after an initial period, once you both know what works. I’ve written about that in should you take performance-based deals.

What happens between the two calls?

You build the proposal from what they said.

  • Use their numbers, not industry averages.
  • Use their words. If they described the problem in a particular way, describe it that way.
  • Note the small personal things. I call them nuggets. They mentioned they haven’t had a holiday in a while, or they’d like more time on the golf course. Keep those.

Don’t send the proposal ahead. Present it. I explain why in how to write a proposal that shows the deliverable.

What should you do on the proposal call?

Put the outcome in big, bold figures. If they want five new clients a month and told you what a client is worth, do the sum and show the total. Don’t leave them to work it out.

Drop the nuggets back in. “That’s the extra revenue, and maybe that holiday.” I can’t tell you to say it on every call. Sometimes people give you nothing, and I don’t force it. This is not the emotional hard sell you may have been on the wrong end of. The question I use to find these is simply “what does success look like for you?”

Say that samples are samples. If you show example work, someone will say “I wouldn’t word it like that”. Tell them up front it’s a sample and you’ll refine it together during onboarding.

Watch their reaction to your biggest number. Only explain it if they pull back. See how to present a big number without scaring off buyers.

Show every option side by side, outcome first. Then recommend one: “From everything you’ve told me, this is the plan that gets you there.” I wouldn’t mention the cheapest option unless they ask. The detail is in how to present pricing options in a proposal.

Check they’re happy with the approach before you show the price. This isn’t something I teach, but I agree with it. If they have doubts about the plan, you want to hear them before a number is on the screen. Otherwise every objection sounds like a price objection.

What if they say they need to think about it?

Find out who else is involved and what that person needs to see. Offer to include them, and book the next call. That’s the third call I mentioned, and it’s normal at this price. The wording is in what to say when a prospect needs someone else’s approval.

If they come back asking for less, trade. If you drop the price, drop the deliverables.

What are the downsides?

It’s slower, and it costs you more time per prospect. If you don’t qualify properly on call one, you’ll spend your week building proposals for people who can’t buy.

It also won’t fix a weak offer. Two calls give a good offer more room. They don’t rescue one nobody wants.

And I haven’t closed every deal I’ve run this way. Nobody has.

What to do next

  1. Decide which of your offers is big enough to need two calls.
  2. Set your discovery call to 30 minutes and take the price slides out of it.
  3. Write down the numbers you need to leave call one with.
  4. Build a proposal template with gaps for their numbers, their words and their nuggets.
  5. On your next discovery call, book the proposal call before you hang up.

If you’d like to work through your own sales process call by call, that’s what monthly mentoring is for.

Frequently asked questions

What is a two-call close?
It's a sales process split across two calls. The first is a discovery call where you learn about the prospect and don't pitch a price. The second is a proposal call where you present a plan built from what they told you, and then the price.
When should an agency use a two-call close instead of one call?
When the work is around $2,500 to $3,000 a month or more, or when there's a chance to upsell or cross-sell the client later. Below that, a single call is usually enough and a second call just adds delay.
How long should each call be in a two-call close?
For work between roughly $3,000 and $10,000 a month, the discovery call is 30 minutes and the proposal call is 30 or 60 minutes. Be prepared for a third call if other stakeholders need to be brought in.
Should I share pricing on the first call of a two-call close?
Not a quote. If they ask, give a range with the bottom set above your real floor, so nobody books the proposal call expecting a fraction of the price. Save the full pricing for the second call, once you've shown the plan and the outcome.
What should I find out on the discovery call?
What they've tried, what a customer is worth to them, how well they know their numbers, when they could start and who else needs to sign it off. Capture their exact numbers and words, because the proposal is built from them.

Want help applying this to your agency?

Monthly 1-2-1 mentoring where you bring the agenda, questions and ideas so we can solve them together. It starts with a free mentoring sprint.