Articles · Pricing & Positioning

Should You Take Performance-Based Deals?

By Mark Colgan ·

Take a performance-based deal only if you’re confident about three things: you know what you’re doing, you can deliver, and you can actually get paid. If you’re unsure about any of them, a retainer or a fixed project is the safer choice, even when you’re just getting going.

This came up with someone who was starting out and had a couple of performance deals on the table from their warm network. Tempting, because a deal is a deal. Here’s what I told them.

What’s the trap with performance-based deals?

Performance is often tied to things you can’t control.

Being paid per meeting booked or per deal closed sounds fair. But think about what has to happen between your work and that result. You generate the interest. The client then has to respond to it, turn up and sell.

You can’t make a client reply to the positive responses you generate. Plenty of them won’t. You’ve done your part, the lead goes cold in their inbox and you don’t get paid.

It’s turning up to a gunfight with a rubber knife.

What should you tie the performance to?

If you do go down this route, tie your pay to what you can influence.

For lead generation, that means something like positive replies, not closed deals. Whether you’re generating enquiries for a local business or conversations for a finance team, you control the quality of what lands in front of them. You don’t control what they do next.

Be prepared for pushback. Many clients will resist paying on anything short of revenue. That’s also why a lot of people avoid performance-based outbound altogether.

Where does your responsibility end?

Be deliberate about this before you sign anything.

Generating positive replies and handing them over is one service. Monitoring an inbox and responding the moment a reply lands is a very different one. The second changes your whole working day.

If you’re going to offer it, price it in properly. Don’t let it creep into the deal because the client assumed it was included.

What to do next

  1. For each performance deal in front of you, ask the three questions: do I know what I’m doing, can I deliver, can I get paid?
  2. Check what the payment is tied to. If it depends on the client’s follow-up, renegotiate it to something you control.
  3. Write down exactly where your work stops and theirs begins.
  4. If inbox management is in scope, give it a price.

If you’d like a fixed fee to fall back on, start with how to price your services when you’re starting out. And if the alternative you’re weighing up is working for nothing, read should you do free work to win your first clients first.

Related: Should You Insist On A Minimum Contract Term.

Frequently asked questions

Should a new agency accept performance-based deals?
Only if you're confident you know what you're doing, can deliver the result and can actually get paid for it. If any of those three is shaky, a performance deal leaves you doing the work and carrying all the risk.
What is the main risk of a performance-based deal?
Your pay is often tied to things you can't control. If you're paid on meetings booked or deals closed, you depend on the client following up on the interest you create, and plenty of them won't.
What should performance pay be tied to?
Tie it to what you can influence. For lead generation, that means something like positive replies, not closed deals. Many clients will resist this, which is one reason a lot of people avoid performance-based work altogether.
Should I manage the client's inbox as part of the deal?
Only if you price it in. Generating positive replies and handing them over is a different service from monitoring an inbox and responding the moment a reply lands. The second one changes your whole working day.

Want help applying this to your agency?

Monthly 1-2-1 mentoring where you bring the agenda, questions and ideas so we can solve them together. It starts with a free mentoring sprint.