How To Present A Big Number Without Scaring Off Buyers
Short answer: say the number and watch their face. If they lean in, say nothing more about it. If they pull back, break the number down into what it means per month or per person and explain what protects the quality. Keep that explanation off the slide.
Why does the same number get opposite reactions?
Most pitches have a headline figure. The volume you’ll produce, the size of the team, the length of the contract, the price.
You say it the same way to everyone. People don’t hear it the same way.
I was talking to an agency owner about this recently. Their pitch led with a large monthly volume. Some prospects loved it. Others had asked for it to be cut in half before they’d sign.
It was the same number each time. To one buyer it sounded like scale. To another it sounded like the low-quality work they’d received themselves, with their name on it.
What should you do when you say it?
Say it, then watch.
Some people lean in. Others physically pull back. On video you can see it. On the phone you’ll hear a pause.
This is one reason I ask for cameras on. It won’t always be possible, and some people give nothing away.
What do you say if they wince?
Have a reframe ready. Two parts:
- Break the number down. What does it mean per month, per week, per person? A content agency’s “sixty articles” is five a month for a year. A big media budget is a daily amount per shop.
- Say what keeps the quality high. Who checks the work, how the list or audience is chosen, what you won’t do. The worry behind the wince is almost always “will this damage my reputation?”
Keep it short. You’re answering a concern you saw, and not delivering a second pitch.
What do you say if they lean in?
Nothing.
They’re already sold on it. If you launch into “now, I know that sounds like a lot, but…” you’ve handed them a worry they didn’t have.
Why not put the explanation on the slide?
Because the slide goes to everyone.
If the defence is on the screen, the buyer who loved the number reads it too. The reframe is only for the people who need it, so keep it in your back pocket.
This applies to any figure that could sound exciting or alarming depending on the buyer. A twelve-month term is commitment to one person and a trap to another. A large team is capacity to one and overhead to another.
What to do next
- Find the biggest number in your pitch.
- Write its breakdown: per month, per person, or whatever makes it feel normal.
- Write one sentence on what keeps the quality high.
- On your next call, say the number, stop, and watch.
For the rest of the pitch, read how to write a proposal that shows the deliverable and how to present pricing options in a proposal.
If you’d like a second pair of eyes on your pitch, that’s what monthly mentoring is for.
Frequently asked questions
- How do I present a big number in a sales pitch?
- Say it plainly and watch the buyer's reaction. If they lean in, move on. If they pull back, break the number down into what it means per month or per person, and explain what keeps the quality high.
- Should I explain a large figure on the slide itself?
- No. Keep the explanation in your back pocket and only use it if the buyer reacts badly. Defending a number to someone who liked it gives them something to worry about.
- Why do some buyers react badly to a big number?
- Because they've been on the wrong end of it. A high volume can sound like scale to one buyer and like a risk to their reputation to another. It depends on what they've experienced before.
- Does this work on calls without video?
- It's harder. You're listening for a pause or a change in tone. It's one reason to ask for cameras on, though some people will keep them off and some give nothing away either way.