Articles · Close More Deals

How To Present Pricing Options In A Proposal

By Mark Colgan ·

Short answer: put every plan on one screen, side by side. Lead with the outcome each plan is expected to produce, then show the price. Explain the single difference between the plan you recommend and the one above it, and recommend one based on what the prospect told you.

What’s wrong with showing one plan at a time?

The prospect can’t compare.

I looked at a proposal recently where the agency owner had built a return calculator. It was good work. But each plan sat behind its own tab, so the prospect saw one projected figure at a time. The return was very different from plan to plan, and nobody on the call would have known unless they clicked through and remembered the numbers.

The comparison is the most persuasive thing on the page. Don’t hide it.

Why show the outcome before the price?

Because of the question it puts in their head.

Say you run an ecommerce agency and your three plans are expected to produce three different levels of extra revenue. When all three sit next to each other, the eye goes to the biggest one. And the thought that follows is:

“What would it cost me to get that?”

That’s exactly what you want them wondering before a price appears. They’ve anchored on the outcome. The price is now a cost of getting there, and not a number floating on its own.

Lead with the price and it works the other way round. They anchor on the cheapest figure, and every plan above it looks expensive.

How do you explain the difference between plans?

One difference at a time.

A table with twelve rows of ticks and crosses makes people’s eyes glaze. Pick the plan you’re recommending and the one above it, and explain the single thing that separates them.

“The difference between these two is that on this one we also run your email flows.”

Then stop. Their appetite decides. Some will stay where you pointed them. Some will reach for the bigger one because they’ve already seen what it could return.

Should you recommend a plan?

Yes. Don’t hand them a menu and wait.

You’ve done a discovery call. You know what they’ve tried before, what a customer is worth to them and how fast they want to move. Use it:

“Based on what you told me about wanting to prove this in one location first, this is the plan I’d start with.”

A recommendation shows you were listening. It also makes the decision smaller. They’re agreeing or disagreeing with you, and not weighing three options from scratch.

When wouldn’t I do this?

If you only have one offer, there’s nothing to compare, and that’s fine. I’ve written about when a single price starts causing problems in how to build pricing tiers with a clear entry offer.

And only show projected results you can stand behind. If the figures are estimates, say so and say what they’re based on. A prospect who feels oversold in the proposal will remember it at the first monthly report.

What to do next

  1. Open your proposal or pricing page. Can you see every plan without clicking?
  2. Put the expected outcome of each plan above its price.
  3. For each pair of neighbouring plans, write one sentence that explains the difference.
  4. Before each proposal call, decide which plan you’ll recommend and why.

For the whole process, read how to run a two-call close. For the rest of the document, read how to write a proposal that shows the deliverable. If they push back on the number, here’s what to do when a prospect asks for a discount.

If you’d like me to look over your proposal before it goes out, that’s what monthly mentoring is for.

Frequently asked questions

Should I show all my pricing options at once or one at a time?
Show them side by side. If each plan sits behind its own tab or slide, the prospect only sees one figure and can't compare. Next to each other, the difference in outcome is obvious at a glance.
Should I show the price or the outcome first?
The outcome. Once someone has seen the biggest result on the page, the question in their head becomes 'what would it cost me to get that?' That's the question you want them asking before you show the price.
Should I recommend one plan or let the prospect choose?
Recommend one, based on what they told you on the discovery call. Then explain the single difference between that plan and the one above it, and let their appetite decide.
How many pricing options should a proposal have?
Enough to show different levels of the work, and few enough to compare on one screen. If the prospect can't see them all at once, you have too many or the layout is wrong.

Want help applying this to your agency?

Monthly 1-2-1 mentoring where you bring the agenda, questions and ideas so we can solve them together. It starts with a free mentoring sprint.