Articles · Book More Meetings

How To Use A Lead Magnet In Cold Outreach

By Mark Colgan ·

A lead magnet gives you a reason to get in touch that isn’t “please buy my service”. Used well, it means you’re sharing something useful that happens to show you know your stuff.

The short version: build one asset your market wants, offer to send it, and don’t do custom work until someone has replied.

What makes an asset worth sending?

It has to be valuable on its own.

An agency founder I know analysed a few hundred ads from the top brands in his niche. He looked at patterns such as whether they used emojis in captions and whether they led with product images or faces. He compiled it into a browsable library with a summary of the top five findings.

That one asset fuelled six months of outbound. Every brand on the list wanted to see what its competitors were doing. He landed four clients in 60 days, built a healthy pipeline of meetings and picked up conference speaking spots from it.

He wasn’t selling in the outreach. He was sharing.

Two types of asset work especially well:

  • What everyone else is doing. People always want to know how others are solving the same problem. That never goes out of fashion.
  • Proprietary data. A survey sent out through your outreach gives you findings nobody can get by asking an AI chatbot.

AI makes building these far faster than it used to be.

Do you need a new one every month?

No. This is where people hide from the real work.

A freelancer I spoke to kept building new lead magnets and suspected he was avoiding outreach. He was right.

Land on one evergreen asset and lean on it. A short best-practices document on what companies in your space are doing right now won’t run out, and you can quietly update it. Don’t make a new one for months if the current one still works.

You can also reuse work you’ve already done. If you built something for a prospect who then ghosted you, you can share it with others in the same market, provided it was built entirely from publicly available information.

The exception is a live client. You’d never hand their work to a competitor.

No. Offer it:

“I’ve prepared something for you. It covers X and Y. Would you like me to send it across?”

It helps deliverability, because there’s no link or attachment. You also get permission and a reply.

Once they say yes and you’ve sent it, keep following up until they tell you to stop. Most people will look at it and go quiet. That’s normal, and it isn’t a no.

When should you do custom work for a prospect?

After they reply.

The same freelancer had been recording personalised video walkthroughs. Hardly anyone watched them. So flip the order. Say you can record a quick walkthrough if they’d like one, and record it when they say yes.

It’s more honest than claiming you’ve made something you haven’t. It also saves you the effort on people who were never going to engage.

Do the same with any tool you’ve built. Tell them roughly what’s out there and offer to run it for them: “I can run this for your business and send you what’s relevant. Would you like me to?” Let the interested ones put their hand up.

The exception is a handful of dream accounts. For those, do the work first and put real findings in the email. The effort is worth it there.

What counts as personalisation?

Not their logo.

Swapping a company’s logo and brand colours onto a landing page is surface-level, and prospects see through it.

Real personalisation is something specific to their business. Run a speed test on their website and show the result. Pull data that’s unique to their situation. The difference is between “here’s a page with your logo” and “here’s what we found when we looked at your setup”.

How polished does it need to be?

Less than you think. A team I worked with brought me a “ten things” asset for marketing leaders before launch. My notes were small:

  • Put the bold text on its own line so it’s easy to scan.
  • Add a category tag in brackets after each point, such as marketing or budget, so readers can find what applies to them.
  • Don’t over-engineer a branded PDF. It ends up looking like a marketing piece from 2015.

It doesn’t need to be perfect. It needs to earn the reply and the meeting.

On the email itself:

  • Only use examples that are true. If it was an illustration someone made up on a call, it doesn’t go in the copy.
  • Make the first line reinforce the subject line. Some people won’t read or remember the subject.
  • Say “other”. “What other marketing teams are shipping” creates a little fear of missing out.
  • Tie it to the calendar. In planning season, refer to the plan they’re writing.

Sending the same three points to everyone is fine for a first test. The better version researches each account, picks the three most relevant points from the ten and sends those. Each email is then largely unique, which also helps deliverability.

What to do next

  1. Pick one asset your market would want even if you weren’t selling anything.
  2. Write the offer email and ask whether they’d like it.
  3. Plan the follow-ups for after you’ve sent it.
  4. Choose a few dream accounts and do the custom work upfront for those only.

Bear in mind that cold email is harder than it used to be, and the right person may simply not see it. The goal is the conversation, through whichever channel works. The same asset can be shared in online communities, and a free or paid audit can do a similar job. If you’re short on proof, the tease also works there: see cold email without case studies.

Frequently asked questions

Should I attach or link a lead magnet in a cold email?
Neither. Offer to send it and wait for a yes. It helps deliverability, you have permission, and you earn a reply, which is the point of the email.
What makes a good lead magnet for outbound?
Something your prospects want in its own right that also shows your expertise. Analysis of what competitors or peers are doing works well, as does proprietary data from a survey.
How often should I create a new lead magnet?
Rarely. Land on one evergreen asset, update it quietly, and only build a new one when the old one stops working. One good asset can fuel months of outreach.
What counts as real personalisation in a lead magnet?
Something specific to the prospect's business, such as the results of a speed test on their website or data unique to their situation. Putting their logo and brand colours on a page doesn't count.

Want help applying this to your agency?

Monthly 1-2-1 mentoring where you bring the agenda, questions and ideas so we can solve them together. It starts with a free mentoring sprint.